The boxes are sound
No water damage, no sagging shelves, no swelling at the base by the dishwasher. The carcasses are the expensive part of a kitchen, and if yours are fine you are mostly paying to change how they look.
Guide
Refinishing your cabinets, or replacing them?
Most kitchens we look at do not need new cabinets. The boxes are solid, the layout works, and what the owner is actually unhappy with is a color that dates the room and doors that look tired. That is a finishing job, and replacing a working kitchen to fix it is an expensive way round.
But not always. Sometimes we open a kitchen and tell people to replace, because refinishing it would be money spent on something that is going to need doing properly in a few years anyway. Here is how the decision actually goes.
When refinishing is the right call
If most of these are true, refinishing will get you what you want for a fraction of the cost and a fraction of the disruption.
The layout works for you
If you are not moving anything, you are not getting the main benefit of a new kitchen. Refinishing changes the look without touching the plumbing, the counters or the floor.
The doors are solid
Solid wood, MDF and even laminate or thermofoil can all be refinished with the right primer. What matters is that they are intact and still hanging square.
Your problem is the color
Honey oak, orange-toned cherry and dark builder maple all date a room badly and all refinish beautifully. This is the most common kitchen job we do.
When we will tell you to replace
We would rather say this at the walkthrough than take the job and have you regret it.
Water has got into the carcasses
Swelling at the bottom of the sink or dishwasher run means the material has gone. Paint does not fix that and will not stop it spreading.
The layout is the actual problem
If the frustration is where things are rather than what color they are, a beautiful finish on the wrong kitchen will not fix it. That is a remodel, not a paint job.
Thermofoil that has already lifted
Once the film has peeled away from the board underneath, that door needs replacing. It cannot be painted back down and it will keep lifting.
You want a different door style
Refinishing changes color and sheen. It does not turn a raised panel into a flat slab. If the door profile is what you dislike, you need new doors at minimum.
What refinishing can and cannot change
Being clear about this up front is what stops disappointment at the end.
Can change: color and sheen
Completely. This is the main event, and the difference in a dated kitchen is dramatic.
Can change: hardware
While the doors are off is the cheapest possible moment to fit new handles or move to soft-close hinges.
Cannot change: the door profile
The shape of the door stays the shape of the door. New doors on your existing boxes is a middle option worth knowing about.
Cannot change: the layout or the counters
Everything stays where it is. That is why it costs so much less.
Depends: wood grain
Oak grain will show through paint unless it is filled and sanded flat first. That is extra work and worth deciding on deliberately — some people like the texture, others are surprised by it.
The other differences people forget
Cost is the obvious one, but it is not the only thing that separates these two options.
A refinish keeps your kitchen usable through most of the work. Doors and drawer fronts leave to be sprayed, so you have open shelving and working drawers for a stretch, and the boxes get done in place. A replacement means the kitchen is out of action, and it usually pulls in counters, plumbing and sometimes flooring behind it.
There is also the waste. Replacing a working kitchen sends a lot of perfectly sound material to a skip, which is worth a thought if that matters to you.
FAQ
Common questions about cost.
How much cheaper is refinishing?
Substantially — you are paying for labor and materials rather than new casework, counter removal and installation. We do not publish figures because kitchens vary too much, but it is the kind of difference that changes what else you can do with the room.
How long do refinished cabinets last?
If the prep is done properly, a long time. The finish is harder than wall paint and made for handling. Where refinished cabinets fail early it is almost always because the grease was not cleaned off or the wrong primer was used — which is why those two steps get the attention they do.
Can you refinish just the doors and leave the boxes?
The boxes and face frames get done too, in place, because a fresh door against a dated frame looks worse than leaving both alone. What is optional is the inside of the cabinets, which most people leave.
What if I want new doors but the same boxes?
That is a real middle option and worth asking about. You keep the carcasses and the layout, get the door style you want, and it still costs far less than a full replacement.
Bring us in for a walkthrough and we will tell you which way your kitchen goes — including when the honest answer is that refinishing is not worth it.
Other services